Question:
How to defend yourself from a knife attack?
anonymous
2010-09-19 10:11:03 UTC
If you're attacked by a thug with a knife is there a way of disarming him without getting stabbed?
Eleven answers:
anonymous
2010-09-19 10:16:34 UTC
shoot him
Stormy
2010-09-21 04:23:30 UTC
I despair at some of the answers above.



The best way do defend yourself in a knife attack is to run away.



If that option isn't open to you, and you are being attacked by someone who is brandishing the knife, letting you know they have a knife, then get an equaliser, a stick, bottle, knife, chain, chair etc.



If this is real life though and not a dojo or hollywood studio, then you will only know they have a knife when you're in the emergency room. So if you're really worried about being attacked by a knife wielding thug you're going to have to think like a knifer. Enrol in a very, very good Fillipino Martial Art and study hard. I also suggest reading "Put 'em Down and Take 'em Out" by Dom Pentecost.



Control their knife hand and forward pressure. However you'll probably get cut or stabbed.
?
2010-09-20 17:19:44 UTC
If you have an avenue of escape & can runaway, that is by far the best course of action.

Otherwise, if you cannot escape, do a quick glance around to see if you have time to pick up an object to keep the attacker at bay & defend yourself.

As a last resort, methods of close-combat will vary according to the way the attacker holds the knife.
anonymous
2010-09-19 17:47:33 UTC
Run away. Sometimes the best defense is to put as much distance between yourself and the attacker as possible. I myself am a boxer, and for years I worked in kitchens and am familiar with knives of all types. There's no defense against someone who makes their living with a knife in their hand. All the defensive strategies people try to give you are speculative and have little to no connection to reality. The worst part is it has very little to do with the knife and everything to do with the attacker. If the person attacking you has experience cutting steaks, you're done for.
callsignfuzzy
2010-09-19 12:34:11 UTC
Knives are dangerous not only for their killing potential, but because often, the victim doesn't even know there's a knife in play until they've been stabbed or cut several times. Odds are, if someone deploys a knife and lets you see it, they're just threatening you. If their plan is to stab you, chances are good that you'll already be stabbed before you know he's got a knife.



Once you know your attacker has a knife, and retreat isn't an option (you should try to retreat first, if at all possible), then the first thing you should do is to find an equalizer. Find something either long enough to keep your attacker at bay or broad enough to use as a shield. A chair or stool accomplishes both objectives. At the very least, you can wrap a jacket, if you have one, around one arm and use it as a shield. I've seen some instructors demonstrate how to use a shoe or a belt in knife defense, but I'm not a big fan of either, as both take some time to deploy (how do you get your shoe from your foot to your hand?) and have some utilitarian problems (how reliable is a flexible belt for wrapping up a speeding fist?)



If you have no equalizer, you must first think about protection. Hold your arms in close, fingers up (vertical forearms) and with your palms facing inward. This protects your tendons and arteries on the inside of your forearm. Hunch down a bit to make yourself a smaller target. Tuck your chin to protect your throat and carotid arteries. Keep your hands near your face. This basic position is similar to boxing's "peekaboo" guard, employed by the likes of and early Mike Tyson or Floyd Patterson. Use the back of your forearm to block or deflect incoming shots.



A lot of martial arts will demo knife disarms from a distance, using an X-block against a giant swing. If your opponent is stupid, they might do this. An X-block is performed by crossing your forearms in the shape of an X and blocking with the outside of them. It's best used when defending an overhand "Psycho" swing or an underhand swing with a knife. Assuming your stop the attacker's momentum with this block (you probably won't, but hey...) you can turn one or both blocking hands over, take control of their attacking arm, and either counter attack with your free limbs (feet, head) or go for a disarm. The most common two-handed disarms are to either twist the knife out of the attacker's hand by driving it towards the thumb (two methods: either grabbing the hilt, which I recommend, or using the forearm against the flat of the blade, which I don't), or by raking along the inside of the attacker's palm and pulling the knife out.



A lot of people will tell you not to clinch with a knife wielding opponent. I'm not one of those guys. The idea is that you're going to get cut anyway, so just accept it, man up, and clinch with them. At least in the clinch, it's easier to control the attacking arm, unlike at a distance. Clinching in this case takes timing. You have to wait until your attacker has either wound up for a big shot or has just missed with an overcommitted swing. You don't reach out and paw at them with your hands; instead, from your peekaboo guard, you step your leg in deep and crash into them. Drive into them as if you were in a burning building and had to crash through a wall to escape. If you knock them over, run away. If you simply connect with their body, use your arms, from their high-and-tight position, to search for a control on their attacking arm. From there you can disarm them, or break their elbow or wrist if you're versed in joint locks. But make it quick. They've got a free hand, and if they have any sense at all, won't just sit there and let you take their toy away.



The fact is that if you're facing a knife, you'll probably get cut. The good news is that after the immediate threat is over, you can put pressure on the wound and get to the hospital. Also, the number of places where knife wounds are almost immediately fatal is a bit limited. Getting stabbed in the shoulder or intestines sucks, but isn't nearly as bad as getting stabbed in the neck or heart.



Finally, there are some people out there who are really good with a knife. They'll probably be prepared for the stuff I've listed here. Some guys are just that good that if you face them, in their element, you'll probably die. That's just a fact.
Aaron R
2010-09-19 10:42:48 UTC
here is the thing the person attacking you is an active force and unless you are starting things you have to be a reactive one action usually beats reaction just about any knife practitioner will tell you that it is not "will you get cut?" it is "you WILL get cut!"



step one is to be vocal make as much noise as possible to call attention to the fact that you are being attacked(scream)



step two is to try to block some of his attacks this is usually accomplished by trying to shove his attacking arm away from you and if the opportunity presents itself hit him somewhere soft





(technically the first 2 steps take place simultaneously step one should not stop till you are safe or you lose your voice) step three is to try to get away run as fast as you can for a crowded area hopefully



to the posters who said to use a gun the person asking the question lives in the united kingdom and it would be easier for you to get an assault rifle and use it as an open or concealed carry legally than he could get a pistol of any caliber and use it similarly



this system only applies to if the thug in question opens with his attack if he instead flashes the knife and demands something you should give it to him it is not worth your life
?
2010-09-19 11:52:40 UTC
Yes, but there's no way for you to learn it without training. Accept te fact that when someone pulls a knife you're going to get cut and probably going to die. At that point theres no difference what you do and it frees you up to try. Your best bet is to learn to defend against the blade with te back of the forearms to reduce severe damage and hope for the best. Of course you could always start training.
moominpics
2010-09-21 09:33:58 UTC
My instructor once told me about 70% of people who SUCCESSFULLY disarm a knife attacker get cut. So the percentage of people who try and fail and get cut must be huge.



If possibler, I'd either RUN or grab a bar stool, broom, dustbin. put a sports bag betwen us as a shield (to give me time to try to get away). Anything to keep him/her at bay.
anonymous
2010-09-19 10:17:37 UTC
Yes. As the attacker draws his weapon, you should whip off your jacket and wrap it swiftly around your forearm. Adopt a boxer's stance with your now protected arm extended to keep the knifeman at distance. With your free hand, find your mobile and without taking your eyes off the potential killer, feel for the raised dot on the keypad to locate where the 9 key is and press it three times with your thumb. When a voice asks 'Emergency. Which service do you require?' answer 'The police please' and wait, still keeping the attacker at bay, while you are put through. A voice will ask 'Police- How can I help you?' thank the voice and explain your predicament. They know your next move so listen carefully.
I know things
2010-09-19 10:14:17 UTC
I'm no expert but i've seen movies.... as the thug would reach out to stab you, move left or right suddenly, grab his arm and yank the knife out of his hand.
Norma
2010-09-19 10:17:21 UTC
Pull out your gun and shoot him.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...